Sinistea #251
SetJapanese Shiny Star V
Year2020
Ungraded
$3.65+$1.32
27 sales · last Jul 4, 2026
CGC 9
$6.00−$6.00
6 sales · last May 18, 2026
PSA 9
$10.99
4 sales · last Jul 2, 2026
PSA 10
$25.00+$9.50
19 sales · last Sep 6, 2025
CGC 10
$13.20
1 sales · last Jun 29, 2026
Sinistea #251 price guide
Sinistea #251 is a collectible Pokémon card from the Japanese Shiny Star V expansion (2020). Setlot tracks 57 recorded sales for this card across 5 grade tiers, 9 of them in the last 90 days. PSA 10 copies have a 90-day median of $25.00. Ungraded copies currently trade around $3.65. The top grade commands 6.8× the ungraded price — grading meaningfully changes what this card is worth. The highest sale on record is $40.00 (PSA 10, May 9, 2025). 41 listings are live right now with asks from $1.80.
Price history
Grading premium
Median graded price vs. the ungraded copy ($3.65) — a rough read on whether grading pays off.
CGC 9
1.6×
$6.00
PSA 9
3.0×
$10.99
PSA 10
6.8×
$25.00
CGC 10
3.6×
$13.20
Live listings
Search on eBay ↗Lowest asks per grade. Older listings may have ended — “seen” is when we last confirmed each one.
| Grade | Listing | Marketplace | Seen | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ungraded 38 tracked | Sinistea 251/190 S4a: Shiny Star V Holo (Japanese) spookyscarysquirtle | eBay | 1mo ago | $1.80↗ |
| Sinistea S 251/190 s4a Shiny Star V Pokemon Card Japanese ash-s_tcg_world | eBay | 1mo ago |
Recent sales by grade· last 90 days
| Grade | Sold | Median | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ungraded | 5 | $3.65 | $1.99 – $5.21 |
| CGC 9 | 2 | $8.40 | $5.99 – $10.80 |
| PSA 9 | 1 | $34.00 | $34.00 |
| CGC 10 | 1 | $13.20 | $13.20 |
Recent sales
| Date | Grade | Title | Sold on | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 4, 2026 | Ungraded | Sinistea S4a 251/190 Shiny Star V Pokemon Shiny Rare Japanese Holo NM/M↗ | eBay | $1.99 |
| Jul 2, 2026 | PSA 9 | 2020 POKEMON JAPANESE SWORD & SHIELD SHINY STAR V #251 SINISTEA PSA 9↗ | eBay | $34.00 |
| Jun 29, 2026 | CGC 10 | 2020 Pokemon Japanese Sword & Shield Star V Shiny Rare Sinistea #251 CGC 10 GEM MINT | — | $13.20 |
| Jun 11, 2026 | Ungraded | Shiny Sinistea S 251/190 S4a Shiny Star V - Pokemon Card Japanese↗ | eBay | $5.21 |
