Magikarp #89
SetMysterious Treasures
Year2007
Ungraded
$2.00−$0.69
95 sales · last Jul 8, 2026
Grade 8
$13.50
2 sales · last Apr 6, 2026
PSA 8
$16.13
1 sales · last Oct 13, 2024
CGC 9
$16.80
5 sales · last May 18, 2026
PSA 9
$21.50
3 sales · last May 21, 2024
CGC 9.5
$10.80
2 sales · last May 19, 2025
CGC 10
$42.88
1 sales · last Jun 25, 2026
Magikarp #89 price guide
Magikarp #89 is a collectible Pokémon card from the Mysterious Treasures expansion (2007). Setlot tracks 109 recorded sales for this card across 7 grade tiers, 68 of them in the last 90 days. CGC 10 copies have a 90-day median of $42.88. Ungraded copies currently trade around $2.00. The top grade commands 21× the ungraded price — grading meaningfully changes what this card is worth. The highest sale on record is $42.88 (CGC 10, Jun 25, 2026). 12 listings are live right now with asks from $1.99.
Price history
Grading premium
Median graded price vs. the ungraded copy ($2.00) — a rough read on whether grading pays off.
Grade 8
6.8×
$13.50
PSA 8
8.1×
$16.13
CGC 9
8.4×
$16.80
PSA 9
11×
$21.50
CGC 9.5
5.4×
$10.80
CGC 10
21×
$42.88
Live listings
Search on eBay ↗Lowest asks per grade. Older listings may have ended — “seen” is when we last confirmed each one.
| Grade | Listing | Marketplace | Seen | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ungraded 12 tracked | Magikarp Common Mysterious Treasures 89/123 HP mtc_binder_fillers | eBay | 1mo ago | $1.99↗ |
| Magikarp LV.13 89/123 Mysterious Treasures Pokémon TCG Diamond & Pearl NM rmnstore_tcg | eBay | 1mo ago |
Recent sales by grade· last 90 days
| Grade | Sold | Median | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ungraded | 64 | $2.00 | $0.69 – $8.62 |
| CGC 9 | 3 | $16.80 | $11.50 – $17.00 |
| CGC 10 | 1 | $42.88 | $42.88 |
Recent sales
| Date | Grade | Title | Sold on | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 8, 2026 | Ungraded | 2007 Pokémon Mysterious Treasures Magikarp 89/123 Common Non Holo↗ | eBay | $2.00 |
| Jul 4, 2026 | Ungraded | Magikarp 89/123 | DP Mysterious Treasures | 2007 Vintage Pokemon TCG Card | LP↗ | eBay | $3.68 |
| Jul 4, 2026 | Ungraded | Magikarp 89/123 Common Mysterious Treasures Pokemon↗ | eBay | $0.69 |
| Jul 1, 2026 | Ungraded | Magikarp 89/123 Mysterious Treasures Pokemon TCG LP↗ | eBay |
![Pikachu [Reverse Holo] #94](https://images.setlot.com/pokemon/pc-pokemon-mysterious-treasures-pikachu-reverse-holo-94.jpg?v=2)
