Magmortar #12
SetMysterious Treasures
Year2007
Ungraded
$3.99−$0.96
76 sales · last Jul 8, 2026
Grade 7
$1.25
1 sales · last Feb 22, 2025
PSA 7
$12.56
4 sales · last Oct 18, 2025
Grade 8
$13.25
2 sales · last Apr 28, 2025
PSA 8
$24.00+$4.01
17 sales · last May 24, 2026
PSA 8.5
$25.00
1 sales · last May 25, 2022
Grade 9
$12.50
1 sales · last Apr 9, 2024
PSA 9
$105.50+$36.50
36 sales · last Jul 9, 2026
CGC 9
$39.99
5 sales · last May 28, 2026
CGC 9.5
$150.00
1 sales · last May 22, 2026
PSA 10
$450.00−$25.00
8 sales · last Aug 29, 2025
CGC 10
$43.00
1 sales · last May 30, 2026
Magmortar #12 price guide
Magmortar #12 is a collectible Pokémon card from the Mysterious Treasures expansion (2007). Setlot tracks 153 recorded sales for this card across 12 grade tiers, 62 of them in the last 90 days. PSA 10 copies have a 90-day median of $450.00. Ungraded copies currently trade around $3.99. The top grade commands 113× the ungraded price — grading meaningfully changes what this card is worth. The highest sale on record is $600.00 (PSA 10, Mar 2, 2023). 11 listings are live right now with asks from $1.99.
Price history
Grading premium
Median graded price vs. the ungraded copy ($3.99) — a rough read on whether grading pays off.
Grade 7
0.3×
$1.25
PSA 7
3.1×
$12.56
Grade 8
3.3×
$13.25
PSA 8
6.0×
$24.00
PSA 8.5
6.3×
$25.00
Grade 9
3.1×
$12.50
PSA 9
26×
$105.50
CGC 9
10×
$39.99
CGC 9.5
38×
$150.00
PSA 10
113×
Live listings
Search on eBay ↗Lowest asks per grade. Older listings may have ended — “seen” is when we last confirmed each one.
| Grade | Listing | Marketplace | Seen | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ungraded 10 tracked | Pokemon Mysterious Treasures Magmortar 12/123 Holo Rare Card MP callahan_253 | eBay | 1mo ago | $1.99↗ |
| Mysterious Treasures #12/123 Magmortar dios.eclect_22 | eBay | 1mo ago |
Recent sales by grade· last 90 days
| Grade | Sold | Median | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ungraded | 45 | $3.99 | $1.30 – $21.50 |
| PSA 8 | 1 | $24.00 | $24.00 |
| PSA 9 | 13 | $105.50 | $80.00 – $162.50 |
| CGC 9 | 1 | $49.95 | $49.95 |
| CGC 9.5 | 1 | $150.00 | $150.00 |
| CGC 10 | 1 | $43.00 |
Recent sales
| Date | Grade | Title | Sold on | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 9, 2026 | PSA 9 | 2007 POKEMON D & P MYSTERIOUS TREASURES MAGMORTAR #12/123 HOLO FOIL PSA 9 B E5↗ | eBay | $97.00 |
| Jul 9, 2026 | PSA 9 | 2007 POKEMON D & P MYSTERIOUS TREASURES MAGMORTAR #12/123 HOLO FOIL PSA 9 A E5↗ | eBay | $94.00 |
| Jul 8, 2026 | Ungraded | Magmortar 12/123 Holo Rare Mysterious Treasures Pokemon Card↗ | eBay | $4.99 |
| Jul 7, 2026 | Ungraded | Magmortar 12/123 Mysterious Treasures Holo↗ | eBay |
![Pikachu [Reverse Holo] #94](https://images.setlot.com/pokemon/pc-pokemon-mysterious-treasures-pikachu-reverse-holo-94.jpg?v=2)
